Renting in Canada? Why Your Landlord's Insurance Won't Save You

Why Your Landlord's Insurance Won't Save You

Rent in cities like Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal is skyrocketing. It’s tempting to cut costs wherever possible. So, when people hear about "Tenant Insurance" (or Renters Insurance), they often skip it.

The common excuse? "My landlord has insurance on the house, so I'm safe."

This is a dangerous myth. Your landlord's insurance covers the building (the walls, the roof). It does NOT cover your clothes, your laptop, or your liability if you accidentally start a fire.

---

What Does Tenant Insurance Actually Cover?

For an average cost of $20 to $30 a month (roughly the price of a takeout pizza), here is exactly what you get:

1. Your Stuff (Contents)

If a pipe bursts inside the wall and ruins your furniture, or a thief breaks in and steals your electronics, your policy pays to replace them. Without it, you pay 100% out of pocket.

(Tip: Standard policies cover internal water damage, but "Overland Water" (flood from outside) is often an add-on. Check if you need it!)

2. Liability (Crucial!)

This is the most important part. Imagine you leave a candle burning and it starts a fire that damages the apartment next door. Or you overflow the bathtub and ruin the unit below.

The landlord (and the neighbors' insurance companies) can sue you for damages. Tenant insurance typically includes $1 million to $2 million in personal liability coverage to protect you from these lawsuits.

3. Additional Living Expenses (ALE)

If your apartment becomes unliveable due to a fire, smoke damage, or flood, where will you sleep? A hotel? A friend's couch?

Your policy covers Additional Living Expenses (ALE). It pays for your hotel bills and food costs while your home is being repaired. This alone is worth the monthly premium.

"Replacement Cost" vs. "Actual Cash Value"

When buying a policy, always ensure you choose "Replacement Cost."

• Actual Cash Value (Avoid): Pays you what your old TV is worth today (e.g., $50 for a 5-year-old TV).
• Replacement Cost (Best): Pays you enough to buy a brand new TV of similar quality (e.g., $500).

The "Roommate Rule" Warning

Do you live with roommates? Be careful. Unlike family members, roommates are usually NOT automatically covered by your policy.

Most insurers require each unrelated tenant to have their own separate policy. If your roommate causes a fire, your insurance might not protect you unless you are specifically named or co-insured. Always declare your roommates to the insurer.

How to Lower the Cost

• Bundle It: Buy your tenant insurance from the same company as your auto insurance for a "Multi-Line Discount" (typically 5-10%).
• Credit Score Check: In most provinces, consenting to a "soft" credit check (which doesn't hurt your score) can lower your premium if you have good credit history.
• Alumni Rates: Check if your university (e.g., U of T, UBC) or employer has a preferred group rate.

The Cheapest Peace of Mind

Many landlords in 2026 are now making Tenant Insurance a mandatory term in the standard lease agreement. But even if they don't, you should get it.

It is arguably the cheapest financial protection available in Canada. Don't risk bankruptcy or homelessness for the sake of saving $25 a month.

(Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. Policy terms vary by provider. Always read your policy wordings to understand exclusions, especially regarding water damage and roommates.)